Showing posts with label extrapolation. Show all posts
Showing posts with label extrapolation. Show all posts

Monday, August 7, 2017

Linked To Does NOT Mean Causes

Recently I came across this Washington Post headline:  “59,000 farmer suicides in India over 30 years may be linked to climate change, study says.”  The article explains that a researcher looked back almost 50 years comparing data and climate information and “concluded that temperature may have ‘a strong influence’ on suicide rates during the growing season.”  Note the words “may have a strong [but unspecified] influence.”  The researcher goes on to project an increase in the number of “lives lost to self-harm” in India.

What are we to make of this?  The number of suicides correlates to the temperature.  Is Global Warming to blame?

Correlation is a mathematical expression of how closely any two measurements move relative to each other.  If the first one gets larger at exactly the same rate as the second, the correlation equals 1, a perfect positive correlation.  If the first one decreases at exactly the same rate that the second increases, the correlation equals -1, a perfect negative correlation.

In our imperfect world this rarely happens, so a correlation of 90% seems to indicate that the two measurements are moving very closely together.  A correlation close to zero shows no mathematical relationship.  The math is not difficult.  A laptop can do it easily and show the graph with points either closely tracking each other for a strong correlation or looking like a random scattering of points for a weak (near zero) correlation.

The most important thing to understand about correlation is that correlation is not causation!  This is a major point of emphasis in every first year statistics class.  Just because two things vary together, they are not necessarily related in any way.

Lots of things get bigger together and are related, like the size of a tree and the amount of lumber available from the tree or the number of pizzas (or amount of beer) needed to feed guests at a party – more people = more pizza.  Gas mileage (MPG) may be related to the size of a truck, the power of the engine or the weight of the load.  These correlations are easy to explain.

When two measures are correlated, sometimes one influences the other, or perhaps they are both affected by some unseen common factor.  Often though, two measures are mathematically related but have no logical link.  Some websites specialize in finding odd examples of these supposed relationships.

Here is one I’ve used before telling about a study correlating dog ownership with eating eggrolls, eating cabbage with having an innie bellybutton, and many others.  Another site, with lovely graphs, correlates the divorce rate in Maine with consumption of margarine, consumption of cheese with the number of people who died by becoming tangled in their bed sheets and several more entertaining examples.  There is the joking relationships between the stock market and skirt lengths or the stock market and the conference of the team that won the last Super Bowl.  I wrote last year about the journalist who compared many measurements and found a surprising correlation between eating dark chocolate and weight loss in one data set.  He later admitted that it was bad science and should not be taken seriously.  If you look hard enough, you can find all kinds of weird examples of data that correlate just by coincidence.  That’s what makes it tricky.

The use of correlation is quite common in studies about health and other areas.  Studies find a mathematical relationship and use the magic word linked.  An action or habit is linked to a healthy or unhealthy outcome.  Eating A is linked to longer or shorter life.  Researchers find relationships that may be the direct, pizza supply to number-of-guests, kind or it may be the cheese to death-by-bed-sheets kind.  But at that point it's only math, not reality.

This is what came to mind when I saw that headline.  To be fair, the researcher tries to explain how there can be an other-than-mathematical relationship.  “High temperatures in the growing season reduce crop yields, putting economic pressure on India's farmers.”  I think any farmer can tell you that weather often increases economic pressure, but how often does that lead to suicide?  Don’t we need more than just two sets of numbers to compare on a graph?  Is this reality or just math?


Whenever critical thinkers hear the word linked, they know someone has found a mathematical relationship.  Researchers hope to discover a real relationship so they can use the word causes, as in action A causes outcome B, but that is much more difficult.  Understanding this is very important to keep from panicking over the latest headline, insisting that someone do something or trying to persuade friends and family to change eating habits to avoid catastrophe.  You don’t have to be a math or statistical wizard to know that linked is not necessarily the same as causes.

Monday, May 14, 2012

Obesity Epidemic and the Food Police


One week ago I wrote about correlation and how it can go wrong by assuming a relationship between two outcomes that may not be valid.  An example given was the common occurrence of both gum disease and heart problems in the same person, which turn out to be not necessarily related as cause and effect.

There is a similar danger with extrapolation, taking a set of data for some time period and projecting it into the future to predict changes.  Extrapolation can be very tricky and is often misleading when all factors are not accounted for or are poorly understood.  One example was given in my comments on climate change (April 27, 2012) where one of the main proponents now says that perhaps he overstated his case.  (Interestingly,  he says he would not have changed his original prediction because that’s the kind of hyperbole that sells books.)  As another quick example consider recent warnings about five-dollar gasoline for this summer that have now been revised downward.  Extrapolation can be dangerous.

Early last week all the news agencies and networks blasted us with dire predictions by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) that the obesity epidemic continues and that 42% of Americans will be obese by 2030.  There are several reasons not to panic.  First, this is just another extrapolation, and we know how unreliable they can be.  Second, it’s something that can be controlled through behavior, but not everyone agrees about that.

There are many examples available of how people can change their behavior and successfully lose weight (including a reality TV show).  Here is an interview with a British actress from last summer.  Pauline Quirke was grossly overweight.  The article refers to her weight in stone (abbreviated st, which equals 14 pounds) so I’ll do the conversion.  In early 2011 she weighed 272 pounds but lost around 100 pounds at the time of the article and is aiming to lose another 20 – and keep it off.  Her motivation came from having a hip replacement before she was 50 years old and not wanting another.  Regardless of motivation, it’s possible to lose weight and keep it off.  If enough Americans are determined to do it, we can make liars of the CDC and be better off for it.

More disturbing though is this article that followed near the middle of last week asserting that it’s not our fault, that we can’t do anything about it.  We are victims of the society and the way our culture has developed.  People have been told about diet and exercise for years; so various parties have given up on voluntary behavior change, instead considering a bunch of heavy-handed political solutions involving, among other things, taxes, tax incentives and more regulations and requirements for schools.  Can you see how these ideas become a direct attack on our freedom?  I guarantee that this will happen (and has happened in the past) each time we don’t take responsibility.  If we don’t fix it ourselves, others will step in with their mandates, programs and artificial incentives, excusing this outside interference as being in the interest of public health.  The choice is clear on this and so many other issues - start doing for ourselves or have "help" inflicted on us.