Here are a few short stories to emphasize the need for
strong behavior in the five key dimensions.
More on Moderation: A
couple of weeks ago I wrote about how perspective leads to moderation in our
wants vs. needs, in our spending, and in what causes we promote and how
strongly we back them. You don’t have to
be a philosopher to understand how moderation leads to a happier life. Now we read about a solar energy operation in California killing birds by scorching them.
They are under investigation by Federal wildlife officials. It closes with a statement from a renewable
energy expert reinforcing this whole idea of moderation. “When it comes to powering the country's
grids, ‘diversity of technology ... is critical … "Nobody should be arguing
let's be all coal, all solar, all wind, or all nuclear. And every one of those technologies has a
long list of pros and cons."
Perspective and critical thinking also make us less
susceptible to hype, the kinds of sales pitches we run across every day on TV,
on line, in print and from our friends and family. One crazy example comes in this short article
about a Jimmy Kimmel prank where he pasted an Apple logo over a $20 Casio
wristwatch and asked people their opinions.
As they say, “You’d be surprised at how many people loved the new
“Apple” product.” This may seem like a silly example, but how
different is it from shopping at Whole Foods or Trader Joe’s and paying extra
for what are hyped as more nutritious and safer products, then finding out
that your peanut butter and almond butter has been recalled “because the
products may be contaminated with salmonella and may pose a health risk”?
A little more perspective helps in many areas. Here is a story about a mom in Houston who
developed (and sells) an app for parents whose children ignore their cell phone
calls. When the call from mom is not answered,
the phone is locked except to dial 911 or call mom back. Parents think it’s wonderful; kids think the
opposite. Many of us remember a time
when no one had a cell phone. If we
wanted to contact a child who was away from home, we must have other
solutions. We also remember a time when
expecting certain (respectful and responsible) behavior from our children did
not call for a technological solution. Does
such an app strengthen a relationship or build resentment. (And how long before some kid markets an app
to override this one?)
Critical thinking and healthcare go together. Many politicians and pundits use the term
healthcare when they really are talking about health insurance. They seem to think that making something
easier to pay for will reduce the price.
In reality, it is more likely to increase usage, and the laws of supply
and demand tell us that, everything else being equal, the price will
increase. It may be cheaper for the
individual patient, but the cost to the overall system will go up. Economic understanding tells us that when the
cost to the system goes up, that increase finds its way back to our wallets,
either in higher premiums paid by us, higher premiums paid by employers which
limits the amount of pay increase, or higher premiums paid by the government
which comes back to us as higher taxes or the negative effects of a larger
government debt. We can’t escape the
higher costs. Fiddling with insurance
does not reduce costs or improve care as so many of the simplistic arguments
want us to believe. Yet these arguments
slide by unchallenged.
As I said last time, many of our problems are self-inflicted
and can only be solved by looking at behavior in light of the five dimensions
and adjusting as needed. It seems too
simple, but next month I will give one reason why this is so difficult.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Click again on the title to add a comment