Sometimes it’s fun to compare and contrast two things that
don’t even appear to be closely related. Consider yoga and smartphones.
Although many practitioners view yoga as merely a set of
good stretching exercises, a good yoga teacher will strongly emphasize the
psychological aspects: focus on your
breathing and try to avoid (or dismiss) mental distractions. Yoga is also associated with mindfulness,
which is again a form of mental focus: paying attention to what you are doing,
whether it be walking or eating.
Mindfulness is moving the focus “off the mat” into daily living.
As we focus in yoga we also become aware of outside
thoughts that creep into the mind.
Recognize and acknowledge those thoughts whether they be hopes, worries,
regrets or whatever. This skill helps
return to the mental focus at the time, but it also is useful in being
otherwise conscious of gut reactions to try to slow down and contain those
reactions long enough for critical thinking to kick in.
Smartphones on the other hand often do just the opposite,
but it goes beyond the distraction of continual nagging ringtones, chirping and
vibration or of pulling out the phone to check it 80 times a day on
average. This Wall Street Journal article paints a far scarier picture. Studies show how the phone can affect the
owner’s concentration and performance, even when it is in an apparently passive
mode.
Research over the last few years suggests that as our brains
depend more and more on technology our intellect weakens. Two studies found the beeping or buzzing
affects owner’s focus and performance “whether they check the phone or not. Sometime just hearing the phone signaling but
being unable to answer it can cause a spike in blood pressure spikes and other
negative physical reactions.
A more worrisome example involved a test of 520
undergraduate students in two areas:
available cognitive capacity (related to ability to focus) and problem solving.
“Some of the students were asked to place their phones in front of them on
their desks; others were told to stow their phones in their pockets or
handbags; still others were required to leave their phones in a different room.” They found that the farther away the students
were from their phones, the better they did; although none reported that the
phone was consciously a distraction.
(The same dynamic shows up in some college classrooms where those who
bring their phone to class generally earn a lower grade.)
But the two are similar in other ways. Yoga and mindfulness have in some ways become
a fad. As I wrote back in August, the
mindfulness-like exercise of walking in the woods is becoming a moneymaking
venture for some who label it forest bathing, which apparently requires a
trained leader. Just last week a reader
sent me another ad for a similar activity offered by a parks and rec department
in Connecticut: hiking yoga for only $25 per session. Brown University warns: “Dependable scientific evidence has
lagged worrisomely behind the rapid and widespread adoption of mindfulness and
meditation for pursuing an array of mental and physical wellness goals.” Many of the claims are based on hype.
Likewise smartphones are promoted with
a great deal of hype. The newest model
is superior to anything on the market and to all competitors. People will stand in line to trade in
perfectly good phones just to be on the cutting edge.
Both smartphones and yoga may also have something of
an addictive quality. As long as
two-and-a-half years ago Pew research already had a category of smartphone dependent. Maybe yoga can help with the
smartphone problem, or maybe it would be a case of trading one addiction for another.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Click again on the title to add a comment